Commentary. The climate debate has acquired a new pressure point: artificial intelligence. At COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, governments and companies are being urged to power AI with cleaner energy through the Antalya AI Pledge, while negotiators argue over whether electrification can advance without extending the life of fossil fuels. That is the right conversation—but the wrong moment for complacency.
Our view is straightforward: the companies building the largest data-centre empires should be required to disclose their electricity use, water consumption and emissions, and should carry a meaningful responsibility for the new power capacity they demand. Voluntary commitments can help establish norms. They cannot, on their own, protect communities from higher bills, strained grids or more pollution.
The issue is no longer hypothetical. Reuters reports that COP31 delegates are divided between calls to accelerate electrification and demands to phase out fossil fuels, while others argue that gas and other conventional fuels are needed to satisfy rising electricity demand from AI data centres and electric vehicles. More than 30 countries have joined Turkey’s voluntary electrification pledge, which aims to raise electricity’s share of final energy demand to 35% by 2035, from roughly 20% today.[Reuters]
That conflict deserves a sober answer rather than a slogan. Electrification can reduce emissions when power comes from low-carbon sources, but simply shifting demand onto an electricity system still dependent on coal or gas does not make the climate problem disappear. Nor does building renewable capacity automatically resolve the questions of transmission, storage, minerals, land and permitting.
There is also a legitimate case for moving carefully. AI tools may improve weather forecasting, energy management and scientific research. Data centres can bring investment and skilled jobs, and reliable power is essential for hospitals, manufacturers and households—not only for technology firms. Governments cannot responsibly sacrifice energy security or affordability in pursuit of targets that ignore local conditions.
But those arguments are strongest when they are used to demand better planning, not to excuse secrecy. If a company’s growth depends on a new power plant, transmission line or water system, the public should be able to see the cost and decide who pays. A data centre should not receive a private subsidy through a family’s electricity bill while its operator advertises an abstract net-zero ambition.
The early response to the Antalya pledge illustrates the weakness of a purely voluntary approach. Reuters reported that Alibaba was the only major technology company to sign the UN-backed promise, while major U.S. companies stayed away. The pledge asks governments and companies to take voluntary steps to power AI with cleaner energy.[Reuters] A framework that leaves the largest firms outside the room may still be useful, but it cannot be mistaken for accountability.
Nor should responsibility fall only on technology companies. Governments determine how grids are regulated, whether new demand is connected before clean capacity is available, and whether poorer countries receive the finance needed to modernise their systems. COP31’s broader dispute over who pays and how quickly economies move away from fossil fuels is inseparable from the AI question.[Reuters]
What a credible bargain would look like
First, disclosure should be mandatory and comparable. Firms should report direct and indirect emissions, hourly electricity demand, water use and the location of new facilities. Annual claims about “renewable energy” are inadequate if a data centre draws carbon-intensive power at the very hours when the grid is under pressure.
Second, new projects should demonstrate additional clean capacity or fund it transparently. That does not mean every facility must operate entirely on renewables immediately; it means expansion should not quietly lock communities into decades of fossil-fuel dependence.
Third, regulators should protect consumers. Large loads should face contracts that reflect the cost of reliability, infrastructure and backup generation. If public support is granted, it should be conditional on jobs, efficiency and emissions performance—not merely on a company’s promise to improve someday.
Finally, international pledges must include progress checks. Reuters reported that only nine of nearly 200 countries represented at the talks had signed the AI pledge by mid-November, underscoring how far rhetoric remains from common rules.[Reuters]
The choice is not between innovation and climate action. It is between unmanaged growth and growth governed in the public interest. AI may become a valuable tool in the energy transition, but that outcome will not be delivered by branding, pledges or optimism. It will come from rules strong enough to make clean power, transparent accounting and fair costs conditions of doing business.