Commentary. The argument unfolding at COP31 in Antalya over the timetable for the next major Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change assessment may sound procedural. It is not. It is a test of whether governments still want climate policy to be governed by evidence—or merely decorated with it.

The European Union and dozens of other countries want the IPCC’s next reports published before the 2028 global review of climate action. Saudi Arabia, China and India are among those pressing for publication in 2029 instead. The dispute has already been described as a threat to the summit’s negotiations, while IPCC Chair Jim Skea has acknowledged operational and reputational risks from the impasse.[1][2]

Our view is straightforward: the reports should be completed in time for the 2028 stocktake, provided the scientific process remains genuinely independent and rigorous. Climate diplomacy cannot keep postponing the moment when it measures whether promises are working.

Why the timetable matters

International climate commitments are meaningful only if governments periodically compare them with observed emissions, warming and adaptation needs. A delayed assessment would not erase the underlying science, but it would deprive negotiators of a common, authoritative reference during a politically consequential review.

That matters because the current negotiations are already strained. Reuters reports that war, inflation and other crises have pushed climate change down many governments’ priority lists, while fossil-fuel producers and major consumers resist firm new targets or explicit language on moving away from oil, gas and coal.[3] In that environment, delay is not neutral. It gives governments more time to avoid uncomfortable conclusions and companies more time to plan around uncertainty.

But the opposing case deserves to be heard. The IPCC’s assessments are extraordinarily demanding, involving thousands of researchers, multiple rounds of review and coordination across disciplines and countries. Rushing publication could create errors, weaken confidence or turn a scientific assessment into a political deadline. If the choice is between a credible report in 2029 and a compromised report in 2028, credibility must come first.

Independence is the safeguard

The answer is not to force scientists into an impossible schedule. It is to separate scientific quality from diplomatic convenience. Governments should agree on a transparent timetable, publish the reasons for any slippage and protect the authors’ ability to identify what the evidence shows—even when that evidence threatens powerful economic interests.

The EU’s pledge to defend climate science at COP31 reflects a legitimate concern: political disputes over the publication date can become a proxy battle over the conclusions themselves.[1] Yet Brussels and its allies should avoid presenting the issue as a simple contest between defenders of science and its enemies. China, India and Saudi Arabia may have strategic motives, but concerns about workload, review standards and fairness in the assessment process are not automatically illegitimate.

Nor should the world treat another IPCC report as a substitute for action. The basic direction of climate science is already clear enough to justify faster emissions cuts, expanded clean power and greater support for vulnerable countries. Waiting for one more assessment before acting would be an abdication of responsibility.

Evidence cannot remain optional

Still, evidence is essential for accountability. Without a timely stocktake, countries can announce progress while emissions remain stubbornly high, and they can claim success using incompatible methods. A shared assessment helps expose those contradictions.

Our newsroom therefore supports a 2028 publication target with three conditions: no reduction in scientific review, public disclosure of the schedule and resources, and a clear fallback plan if sections cannot be completed on time. Governments should fund the process rather than bargain over its conclusions. They should also commit now to using the assessment—whenever it is delivered—to revise national policies.

COP31’s central question is not whether diplomacy should control science. It is whether diplomacy will allow science to control the promises diplomacy makes. The answer should be yes. A report can be delayed for defensible technical reasons; it should never be delayed because its findings are politically inconvenient.

Sources