Commentary. At the end of another United Nations climate summit, negotiators appear close to proving a dispiriting point: governments can agree on the language of transition more easily than on the substance of change. The latest draft at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, reportedly omits the words “fossil fuels,” even as countries debate how to increase electrification by 2035. That omission is not a technical footnote. It is the central political fact of the meeting.

Our view is straightforward: a credible climate agreement must name the problem it claims to address. That means identifying coal, oil and gas while setting measurable, funded pathways to reduce their use. An agreement that celebrates more electricity without saying how that electricity should be generated could allow fossil-fuel power plants to count as progress. Electrification is valuable only when it materially cuts emissions.

The case for explicit language is both scientific and democratic. Citizens deserve to know whether their governments are committing to cleaner energy or merely expanding energy consumption under a more attractive label. Investors and local authorities also need clear signals before committing billions to grids, public transport, storage and renewable generation. Vague wording shifts risk onto everyone else.

Activists and several national leaders have therefore criticized the draft, arguing that leaving fossil fuels unmentioned weakens the summit’s purpose. A coalition advocating a faster transition is still seeking new commitments despite Colombia’s withdrawal, a sign that pressure for a clearer global road map has not disappeared. The Associated Press reported that the draft’s proposed electrification target would raise electricity’s share of total global energy consumption from roughly 21% to 35% by 2035, without requiring that the new power come from renewables.

Still, the opposing arguments deserve more than dismissal. Governments in emerging economies face rising demand for affordable electricity, industrial development and jobs. Some say a rigid fossil-fuel phaseout could punish countries that contributed relatively little to historical emissions while wealthy states retain more financial and technological capacity. Others support carbon capture, nuclear power or transitional gas as tools that can keep energy reliable while cleaner systems are built.

Those concerns are real. A just transition cannot be reduced to a slogan, and poorer countries should not be asked to choose between climate safety and basic development. The summit’s disputes over adaptation finance, carbon capture and Europe’s carbon border measures show that the argument is not simply “climate action versus denial.” It is also a fight over who pays, who moves first and which technologies count.

But acknowledging those constraints does not justify linguistic evasion. A climate agreement can recognize different national circumstances while still stating that global fossil-fuel dependence must decline. It can support carbon capture where emissions are genuinely difficult to eliminate without allowing the technology to become a blanket excuse for continued expansion. It can pair stronger targets with grants, concessional finance and technology transfer.

The same principle applies closer to home. The Trump administration is asking the Supreme Court to allow the Environmental Protection Agency to cancel $16 billion in Biden-era climate grants. The legal dispute will test not only the fate of those funds but also how easily one administration can dismantle programs created by another. AP reported that the case is the largest grant-cancellation dispute of its kind, while challengers argue that the EPA acted unlawfully and unconstitutionally.

Supporters of the administration’s position may argue that elected governments should be able to redirect public money and end programs they consider wasteful or legally flawed. That is a legitimate accountability principle. Yet climate policy becomes uniquely fragile when each election can erase long-term investments, leaving communities, workers and businesses unable to plan.

At COP31, the minimum standard should be clarity: name fossil fuels, set verifiable milestones, protect vulnerable economies and attach money to promises. Compromise is necessary in diplomacy. But compromise should narrow the route to a solution, not conceal whether a route exists at all.

Sources