Commentary: Europe has chosen the language of climate leadership again. The European Union’s amended Climate Law now sets a legally binding target to cut net greenhouse-gas emissions by 90% from 1990 levels by 2040, while allowing a limited contribution from high-quality international credits. That is a serious commitment. It is also only the beginning.
Our view is straightforward: the EU should defend the ambition of the target, but stop treating the announcement of a target as evidence that the work is succeeding. Climate policy is ultimately judged in power stations, factories, farms, transport systems and household budgets—not in council conclusions.
The case for the 90% goal is strong. The OECD’s 2026 Climate Action Monitor says national climate policies have continued to expand, but momentum has slowed and uncertainty about implementation is growing. Meanwhile, Climate Action Tracker warns that current global policies point toward a prolonged overshoot of 1.5°C and says emissions cuts must accelerate sharply. Europe cannot solve that global problem alone, but abandoning ambition would make it harder for anyone else to move.
Nor is the EU’s record simply one of failure. Oxford’s Climate Policy Monitor reports that climate-policy frameworks continue to expand worldwide, with Asia, Latin America and Africa increasingly driving policy innovation. That matters: the transition is not solely a European project, and evidence of progress exists even amid political backlash.
The credibility gap
The problem is the distance between legislation and delivery. The European Commission has urged nine member states, including Germany, Italy and Sweden, to submit corrective plans to accelerate cuts in transport, buildings, agriculture and waste. If even climate frontrunners are being asked to catch up, the Union’s principal weakness is not a shortage of objectives. It is uneven execution.
This gap creates a credibility problem. Governments can promise deep reductions while postponing difficult decisions about grid expansion, permitting, industrial investment, public transport and energy prices. Citizens then experience climate policy less as a coherent transition than as a sequence of costs and confusing rules. That is fertile ground for parties arguing that climate action is an elite project imposed without consent.
The counterargument deserves respect. Europe is operating under genuine economic pressure. Energy-intensive industries face global competition, households remain sensitive to prices, and rapid regulation can produce compliance costs before cleaner alternatives are available at scale. A rigid path could encourage production—and emissions—to move elsewhere. The limited use of international credits in the 2040 framework reflects, in part, an attempt to preserve flexibility.
Flexibility, however, must not become an escape hatch. Carbon credits can supplement domestic reductions; they cannot substitute for them. Nor should competitiveness be defined as protecting every incumbent business model. Europe’s long-term economic interest lies in building the technologies, infrastructure and skills that a decarbonising world will need.
Make the transition tangible
The EU should therefore pair its target with a more practical political bargain. First, it should publish clearer sector-by-sector milestones and identify which governments are off track. Second, it should direct more support toward lower-income households and regions dependent on carbon-intensive industries. Third, it should simplify permitting and coordinate investment in grids, storage and clean manufacturing. Enforcement and fairness are not competing priorities; each makes the other possible.
Climate policy also needs intellectual honesty. The EU should acknowledge that some measures will fail, revise them when evidence demands it and explain who pays during the transition. A government that promises painless change invites distrust. A government that explains the trade-offs—and shares them fairly—has a better chance of maintaining public support.
Europe’s 2040 target is worth defending because retreat would be worse. But targets are not achievements, and leadership is not a press release. The test now is whether European governments can turn a legally binding number into cheaper clean energy, resilient communities and credible emissions cuts. On that test, applause should wait.
